r1///
[This base of recollection, thus developed and cultivated,] leads to the penetration
[of any elements.] This is called 'the base of recollection.’
///r2 with regard to this, a monk who goes forth mindfully and [returns] mindfully …
r3///
… [The Blessed One] said this (and so on, up to) [Ānanda] applauded [the Blessed One’s speech]. [End of section] 4.
*Citra-sutra
§ 1b
v1///(ayusma)[da maha]mogalyanena ◦ mahakaṣyavena a[ya]v2(smada)///(pac̄abha)ta peṃḍacarapratikraṃta kariramaṃḍalav3(maḍe)///(saṃ)[ni]patito so spi ti therana bhikṣuna dharmav4(vinayakatha)///.. anmagamehi therana bhikṣuna dharmavin[a]xr1(yakatha)///r2///r3///v1///v2///v3///
v1///
… with venerable Mahamogalyana, with Mahakaṣyava, with venerable v2 [Mahakacayana]
… ///
… [after taking their] meal and having returned from their alms round, [assembled]
in the Karira pavilion hall.
v3///
… joined the assembly. “Here I am!,” [he interrupted] the elder monks’ [discussion
of] the teaching [and the discipline] …
v4///
“… wait for [the end of] the elder monks’ [discussion] of the teaching and the discipline.”
///r1///r2///r3///v1///v2///v3///
r1///.. … of the Blessed One …
///r2///
[This thought occurred] to venerable Mahamogalyana.
///r3/// to [that] time, [a monk] named Tiṣya [had recently died].
///v1///
[The brahma-gods] know [him] as “Tiṣya” …
///v2///
[It has been long since you took the opportunity] for coming [here] (and so on), up
to …
///v3///
… Tiṣya the brahmā ….. ///
r1///
[Three evil, unwholesome] thoughts have beset [me], as follows (as before, up to)
hurtful thoughts; and so on. He … ///r2///
[Five] dharmas are conducive to the maturation [of immature mind liberation and wisdom
liberation]. Which five? Among them, Mekhiya, a monk who has a good companion … ///r3///
[This is the first practice that] is conducive to [the maturation of immature mind
liberation and wisdom liberation]. ‹Second dharma:› [A monk who] remains devoted to
development with respect to the virtues which are dear to the noble … ///v1///
… leading to [concentration]. Mekhiya, [this is the second practice conducive to the maturation] of immature mind liberation
[and] isdom liberation … ///v2///
‹Third dharma:› [… conversation] conducive to purification of the mind, as follows:
conversation about desiring little, conversation about contentment, [conversation
about] seclusion … ///v3///
… [and] conversation about knowing and seeing [liberation]; he becomes one who gets
to [to hear] such kinds of conversation, who gets to hear it at will, who [gets to
hear it] easily. ///
*Nirvanasukha-sutra
§ 4
4r1///
ya ya nu aya avaso nanu aya [dukha h](i)///r2///(anato a)gaśa ti agaśacayadano va[sa](paja)///r3///(aü)[sa] ta imena pa[r]yagena (v)[e](didavya)///v1///(pi)[ya]la yava sukha nirvano i
///v2///(bha)[ga]vato dukha hi aüsa ta i(mena paryagena)///v3///(vihara)[to] akicañaya[dana]sahaga[to sa](ñamanasigara)///
r1/// and as for this affliction, now wasn’t this [said by the Blessed One to be] just
suffering?
///r2///
… [realizing that] space [is endless], he enters the sphere of the infinity of space
[and remains there].
///r3///
… Friend, it is in this way that it is to be understood [that nirvāṇa is pleasurable].
///v1///
… and so on, up to: nirvāṇa is pleasurable. ///v2///
[As for this affliction, wasn’t it said] by the Blessed One to be just suffering?
Friend, it is in this [way that] it [is to be understood that nirvāṇa is pleasurable].
///v3///
… as he dwells [there], perceptions [and thoughts] associated with the sphere of nothingness
… ///
*Gavi-sutra (?)
§ 5
5r1///
.[o] .[rohi] rupo [akhadi]da ti .. ///r2///.. [y].[ni] tu imani tvina .. .. ///r3///.. .. ///v1//////v2///(ye)[hi n]imite[hi] yehi [u](deśehi)///v3///(na ase)[va]ti na bhaveti na bahuli[ka](roti)///
r1///
… ? ? form; uneaten grass … .. ///r2///.. … but these grasses [?] which … .. .. ///r3///
…
///v1//////v2///
… by which objects, by which indications …
///v3///
… he does not practice [them], he does not cultivate [them], he does not develop [them]
…
///
*Mahapraṣ̄a-sutra
§ 6
6r1///[d].no ase aropayitva yena bha(gava)///r2///.. ṣi añatirthigehi parivraja(gehi)///r3//////v1//////v2///(na a)[bhi]nadi na pratikrośi anabhina[di](t)v[a]///v3///(vyagari)ṣyati tasya nu dhariṣyama{ṃ} a[s].///
r1/// having lifted … to the shoulder, [they approached] the Blessed One … ///r2///.. … [we exchanged greetings] with [those] non-Buddhist mendicants …
///r3//////v1//////v2///
[We] neither applauded nor rejected [what the non-Buddhists said]. Without applauding,
[without rejecting their words, we thought “Let us go to the Blessed One and report
this matter to him.”] ///v3///
[As the Blessed One] will explain [it to us], so will we retain it.” Then [they] …
///
r1///
[It is because these ten qualities exist in the world that not-dharmic or incorrect
behavior,] or [dharmic] or correct behavior [are observed. The Blessed One] said this.
[The Licchavi Mahali was pleased and applauded the Blessed One’s speech]. ///
*Triṣ̄a-sutra
§ 7b
r2///(bhi)[kṣu bha]gavada pracaśroṣi bhagava na [i](do)///r3///(prañaya)[t]i yapracaga bhavatriṣ̄na bhavatriṣ̄a [bh](ikṣava)///v1///(na) anaharo ko ya aharo bhavatriṣ̄naya [a](vija)///v2///(pa)[ca] aho nivarana saharo va[d]emi [na a](naharo)///v3///(k)[o] ya ahar(o)[tina d](u)[c̄arida](na)///
r2///
[“Yes, sir,”] the monks replied to the Blessed One. The Blessed One [said: “No ultimate
origin for craving for becoming is perceived, such that [before] this [craving for
becoming did] not
[exist]. ///r3///
[But, monks,] it is observed that craving for becoming is dependent on something.
Craving or becoming, monks, [I say, has a nutriment;] ///v1///
[craving for becoming does] not lack a nutriment. And what is the nutriment of craving
for becoming? ‘Ignorance’ [is the answer to this]. ///v2/// the five hindrances, I say, have a nutriment;
[they] do not lack [a nutriment]. ///v3/// And what is the nutriment of the three bad actions? ///
*Mulaga-sutra
§ 8a
8.1r1//////r2///(ki)masivatea kipramukha kiutara kisara ki[pa]ryavasana sarva dh[a]rm[a e](va)///r3///(dha)r(ma no bha)[gavatanetiya] bhagavatapratisaran[a sadh](u)[bha](t)[e]///v1///(mana)[s](ika)[r](o)[sa bhaṣiṣyama] eva bhata [t](e)[bh](i)(kṣu)///v2///(sa)[r](va) dharma piyalo yava kiparyavasana [sa]rva dharma eva proṭhaya tusme [aña](tirthigana)///v3//////8.2r1//////r2///(cha)[da]mulaga aüsa ho [sa](rva dharma)///(pha)[rśa]sa[mu](daya)///r3///[p](r)[añu]tara s[a](rva dharma)///(nirvanaparyava)[sa]na sarva dharma ///
r1//////r2///
“‘What is the authority [of all dharmas], what is their head, what is their superior,
what is their essence, what is the conclusion of all dharmas?’ Thus [asked] …” ///r3///
“[For us,] the Blessed One is the guide of the dharmas, the Blessed One is their recourse.
Please, sir …” ///v1///
“Pay attention [well]; I will explain.” “Yes, Sir,” [responded] those monks [to the
Blessed One]. ///v2///
“If asked thus, ‘[What is the root] of all dharmas?’ and so on, up to ‘What is the
conclusion of all dharmas?,’ you [should explain] to the non-Buddhists …” ///v3//////r1//////r2/// all [dharmas], friend, have desire as their root. /// xxx
///r3/// all [dharmas] have wisdom as their superior. /// all dharmas have [nirvāṇa] as their conclusion …” ///
*Pravaya-sutra
§ 8b
/// tasmad (aüsa)///v1///(ani)[ca]sañapa[ric](ito)///(aśu)[bha]sañapari[c](i)(to)///(sañapari)cito [p](ahanasañaparicito)v2///(tasañaparici)to logasya sabha[va](ca vibhava ca ñatva)///[pa]rici[t](o)///v3//////
/// Therefore, friend, [you should train yourselves in this way: …]///v1///
… strengthened by the perception of impermanence … ///
… strengthened by the perception of repulsiveness … ///
… strengthened [by the perception of the coming into being and passing away of the
world]; [strengthened by the perception f] abandonment … ///v2///
… [having known the growth and decay of the world], strengthened [by the perception
of that]; [having known] the coming into being [and passing away] of the world …///
… strengthened [by] … ///v3//////
*Kidriṭhiga-sutra
§ 9.1
9.1r1///[na]ha bhate janami kidriṭhiyo bhagava na heva tva grihapati janasi kidriṭhigo śramaṇo
go[da]mo atha kidriṭhigo sya bh[i]kṣu(sagho)///r2///(naha bhate janami ki)driṭhigo bhikṣusagho na hi tva gahapa[ti] janasi kidriṭhigo śramano godamo napi janasi kidriṭhiga s[y]a bhikṣusagho atha ki[dri](ṭhigo si tva)///r3//////v1//////v2///(bhoti ca na ca bhoti tadaga)to paramarano bhoti na ca bhoti na nu bhoti tadagato paramarana idam eva sa[co] mokham a[ño] eva[dri]ṭhi[go] ham a[spi] aña[ti](rthiga parivrajaga)///v3///(anathapiḍada graha)[pa]ti [e]dad avoci vyagrida kheto grahapati etehi parivrajagehi yathaspagadriṭhiga atha [vya]garohi kidriṣṭhiyo tva
///
r1/// [Anāthapiṇḍika:] “Sirs, I do not know what views the Blessed One holds.”
[Anyatīrthikas:] “Householder, you don’t even now what views the śramaṇa Gotama holds. Then what views does his [assembly of] monks hold?”
///r2///
[Anāthapiṇḍika:] “Sirs, I do not know what views the assembly of monks holds.” [Anyatīrthikas:] “Householder, you don’t even know what views the śramaṇa Gotama holds, nor do you know what views his assembly of monks holds. Then what views do
you hold?” ///r3//////v1//////v2///
[Anyatīrthikas:] “… A tathāgata [both exists and does not exist] after death.” “A tathāgata exists
and does not exist and does not not exist after death. Only this is the truth; [all]
else is wrong. This is my view.” The non-Buddhist [mendicants] ///v3/// said this to the householder [Anāthapiṇḍika]: “Householder, this (?) has been explained by these mendicants, each according to
his own view. Now, you explain: what views do you hold?” ///
§ 9.2
9.2r1//////r2///(ya kho)[va]◯na kici bhuto saḱr̥to praticyasamuparno tam anico ya anica ta dukho ya d[u](kho)///r3///(yo)[p]i aya pari(vra)[ja]go evam aha aśaśvato logo ata ⟨lo⟩go anata ◦ ta jivo ◦ ta śari(ro)///v1///(para)mararno bh[oti na] ca bh[u]ti na ca bhoti na nu bh[u]ti tadagato paramarano idam eva ///(saco mokham año)///v2///(upa)[r](n)o pa◯raghoṣapracyago ya kho vana kici
praticasamuparno tam anico ya a(nica)///v3//////
r1//////r2///
“But whatever has come into being, is conditioned, (or) is dependently originated,
is impermanent. What is impermanent is suffering. What is suffering [is not mine,
is not I, is not my self …]” ///r3///
[Anāthapiṇḍika:] “And as for this mendicant who said this: ‘The world is not eternal’… [And as for
the one who said this:] ‘The world is finite …’
[And as for the one who said this: ‘The world] is infinite …’ [And as for the one
who said this:] ‘Soul and body are one and the same …’ ///v1///
[And as for the one who said this: ‘A tathāgata both exists and does not exist] after
death…’ [And as for the one who said this:] ‘A tathāgata exists and does not exist
and does not not exist after death. Only this [is the truth; (all) else is wrong’]
… ///v2///
… [This view arises from (his own) improper attention, or] is based on the voice of
others. But whatever is dependently originated is impermanent. What is im[permanent
is suffering …]
///v3//////
§ 9.3
9.3r1//////r2///(ya kho)[va]na kici bhuto saḱr̥to praticyasa[mu](parno tam anico ya anica ta dukho)///r3///
dreṣṭhavya tasya ca darśanaya sa[kṣi](kriyae)///v1///(tu)[ṣni]bhuda makabhuda prasthakadha adho(mukha)///v2///(vi)ditva uṭ́haya m a{ṃ}sanato prakami ye[na](bhagava)///v3//////
r1//////r2///
… But whatever has come into being, is conditioned, [or] is dependently originated
[is impermanent. What is impermanent is suffering. What is suffering] … ///r3///
… [that] should be seen [as it really is, with right wisdom, in this way ‘This is
not mine; I am not his; this is not my self.’] And it is in order to see that [truth],
in order to experience [it, in order to comprehend it, that one practices the holy
life under the Blessed One”]. ///v1///
[When Anāthapiṇḍika had thus spoken, those mendicants] fell silent, ashamed, their shoulders drooping,
[their faces] downcast … ///v2///
… [having known (?) that, the householder Anāthapiṇḍika] got up from his seat and proceeded to where [the Blessed One was].
///v3//////
*Upali-sutra
§ 10
10r1///[bha]gavato pada vadi(tva)///r2///(prati)[s](evitu d)[uravisabhavana u]pali rañavanapra[sta](na)///r3///(sa)[gha] te upali vi[hara]to phaṣo bha[vi]ṣyati dvetiyaga [pi upa](li)///v1///(upa)[li] ti viha[ra]to phaṣ[o bha]viṣyati ◦ yo upali eva mañe[ya a]haṃ
///v2///(upi)[lava ya tada kis](ya)[hedu] harati upali
///v3///
rayaniyo vaso
///
r1///
… bowed to the Blessed One’s feet … ///r2///
… to frequent …” “Hard to endure, Upāli, are the wilderness and forest tracts … ///r3///
… it will be comfortable for you, Upāli, dwelling in the saṅgha.” Again, for a second time, Up(āli) … ///v1///
“… It will be comfortable, Upāli, for you dwelling (in the saṅgha). Upāli, one who might think thus: ‘(Not achieving concentration), I … ///v2///
… (sinking down) and floating away. What is the reason for that? Upāli, (the forests) distract
(the mind) … ///v3///
… an attractive residence …” ///
*Nagulapita-sutra ?
§ 11a
11.1r1///.. .. + [mri]da u paneti a[pr]... ///r2///[v]iharati śuśumaragi[r](e)///r3//////
r1///
… ?? but thus ?? …
.. ///r2///
… is dwelling at Śuṃśumāragiri …
///r3//////
*Sadha-sutra
§ 11b
v1//////v2///(dr)[o]niya nibadho samana [yava](sa)///v3///
ma [e]vam evo iśegacu p[u]r[u](ṣakhaḍuko)///11.2r1///[y]o na pridhiv[i] n[iśrayo j̄]ayati na avo n[i]śrayo j̄ayati na teyo [ni](śrayo j̄ayati)///r2///(neva)sañanaasañayadano na ima logo niśrayo j̄ayati n[a pa](ralogo)///r3//////v1//////v2///
na niśrayo j̄ayati kada j̄ayi bhate bhadre puruṣayani[yo]///v3///(na nevasañanaasañayada)[no] niśrayo j̄ayati (na) ima logo na paralogo ya pi ta dri[ṭha]///
v1//////v2///
“[A wild colt], being tied at a feeding trough,
[meditates] ‘Fodder, [fodder!]’ ///v3///
… In just the same way, here some person
[who is like a wild colt] … ///r1///
… who meditates without depending on earth, meditates without depending on water,
[meditates] without de[pending] on fire … ///r2///
… [meditates without depending on] the sphere of neither-perception-nor-nonperception,
meditates without depending on this world, [meditates] without [depending on] the
next [world] …
///r3//////v1//////v2///
… meditates without depending [on that either.]” “Sir, meditating in what way does
an excellent human thoroughbred, …” ///v3///
“He does not meditate depending on the sphere [of neither-perception-nor-non-perception],
(nor) [depending on] this world, nor on the next world, [nor] on whatever has been
seen … ///
*Moranivapa-sutra
§ 12a
12r1///r2///v1///v2(vija)r1caranasaparno so śreṭho d[e]vavamanuṣyana idam a[va](ci)///
r1///r2///v1///v2 [“The person who is] endowed with [true knowledge and] good conduct is the best of
deities and humans.” … said this … ///
r2 Monks, when mind liberation with loving kindness as been practiced … ///v1… eleven results, eleven benefits are to be expected. Which [eleven]? ///v2 He is [dear to non-humans.] The deities protect him. A weapon does not affect him,
poison [does ot affect him, fire does not affect him …] ///
a1///.. … seated to one side … ///a2///.. … reports to Ānanda … ///b1///. … should be ?? What is the reason for that? ///b2/// … Ānanda [went to] where the Blessed One [was]
… ///